In all honesty, from a guys perspective, if the first guy truly loved her, then he would let her go and let her move on so she could meet new people. Being in love implies that you just want the other to be happy. If it's pretty obvious he's hurting her, he should be a man and let her have the chance to be happy, even if it means her being with someone else.
My name is Jacob (but I prefer Jake) Bowden! I'm 14 and I sing, dance, and play the guitar, drums, and the piano :) I play football, soccer, and basketball lol I LOVEEEE EMMA STONE, She's my babe :)